Western Europe

Dutch Public Prosecution Service opposes bill on termination of life of minors

The top level of the Dutch public prosecutor's office, the Public Prosecution Service, rejects the draft regulation on the active termination of life in children aged 1-12 years, which is currently being finalised.

Such regulation is redundant, and the current draft regulation drawn up by the Ministries of Public Health and Justice can also be criticised in terms of content, according to the responsible Attorney General Rinus Otte. The top magistrate writes this in an advisory report requested by the Ministry of Public Health.

The Euthanasia Act, which came into force in 2002, regulates the conditions under which doctors may decide to euthanise patients aged 12 years and older. In addition, in 2007, the government of then Prime Minister Jan-Peter Balkenende made an additional regulation intended for active termination of life for babies aged 1-12 months. The core of this regulation is that an assessment committee consisting of two doctors, a lawyer and an ethicist examines whether a doctor has acted with due care. If they come to that conclusion, such a judgement is considered weighty advice to the public prosecutor not to prosecute.

Don't do it

A select group of paediatricians has been urging for years that such an arrangement should also be made for children aged 1-12. This call was answered by then health minister Hugo de Jonge in 2020. Minister Ernst Kuipers is now consulting various parties on the draft regulation that was subsequently drawn up. But the public prosecutor's response is clear: do not do it.

Otte writes that paediatricians do not yet have a crystallised professional norm about what kind of suffering is so unbearable that only life termination can end it. Such a norm should be in place if the doctor can invoke force majeure. The regulation that has now been drawn up offers scope to weigh current suffering and future suffering, which doctors expect to recur regularly.

The document also assigns weight to parents' suffering, but the public prosecutor believes that the required consensus among doctors on this issue is lacking.

The Board also considers that the regulation will not contribute to making the actions of physicians more transparent, although that is the objective. According to the draft regulation, the Public Prosecutor's Office remains the authority that decides on the prosecution. This makes doctors reluctant to report to the evaluation committee, as an earlier evaluation study revealed.

The OM also believes that the room that the existing criminal law already offers to doctors who want to invoke force majeure is sufficient.

Mortality expectancy

In drawing up its advice, the Public Prosecution Service sought the advice of two renowned experts who have already published a series of articles on the problematic aspects of active termination of life in the case of (incapacitated) children. Both are critical of the document that Kuipers has sent for advice. Health lawyer Dr Jo Dorscheidt, for instance, accuses the doctors who pushed for the regulation of a form of “medical-professional activism” that wrongly relativises the importance of an external, judicial review of life-terminating acts on minors.

Professor of Criminal Procedure Paul Mevis also calls the regulation premature and wants more control for the judge at this stage. The lawyer thinks it would be more prudent to create a general rule only after the judiciary has been allowed to investigate a concrete criminal case several times. In the Netherlands, this has only happened once so far.

When De Jonge announced the regulation in 2020 in the Dutch House of Representatives, he had already made a start with its contents. One of the requirements would be that termination of life would only be permitted for children who are expected “to die within the foreseeable future”, the minister outlined. That criterion appears to have been scrapped in the meantime, the argument being that mortality expectancy is a relative concept that cannot be captured in a specific time frame.

Majority not necessary

“Not very convincing,” says Mevis. He points out the risk that by dropping this requirement, the medical prognosis and the appreciation of future suffering can also be a ground for termination of life.

The OM shares this concern and warns that this may conflict with the international Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC). It follows from this convention that member states should recognise that a disabled child should have a full and decent life. “Handicapped children are therefore entitled to special care. All this does not mean that the termination of the life of a seriously ill child, who suffers hopelessly and unbearably, is excluded in advance. However, it does mean that careful attention must always be paid to ensure that more permissive legislation and regulations in this area do not conflict with human rights. Certainly not, where it concerns the termination of the lives of (multiple) disabled children”, according to the OM.

It is not yet known when minister Kuipers will present the regulation to the Lower House. As it is not a legislative amendment, acceptance by a majority of votes is not necessary. However, the decision-making process can be postponed as long as the House requests additional written clarification.

*This article was translated by CNE.news. It was published previously in Reformatorisch Dagblad on April 11th, 2022.*

Back to top button