Southern Europe

Italian church wants (shallow) research of abuse

As one of the last parishes, the Roman Catholic Church in Italy has plans to investigate sexual abuse within the church. However, she does not seem very keen on examining the past thoroughly.

Gualtiero Bassetti, head of the Italian conference of bishops, stated that the Italian bishops are thinking about starting an internal investigation on sexual abuse within the church.

If the investigation would actually be started, it would be a breakthrough because Italy is one of the few countries that did not appoint a special commission. The country is usually seen as one of the most Catholic nations in the world. It is also the home of the pope.

It is still unclear what the investigation would look like. Following Bassetti's words, it is unlikely that the Italian church leaders will examine the past as thoroughly as the French church leaders did recently. “In choosing a research method, we have to keep in mind the structural, cultural and ecclesiastical differences between our country and others”, cardinal Bassetti said to Corriere della Sera.

According to Bassetti, the most significant difference is the ratio between statistical numbers. In Italy, there is an estimated number of 40 million Roman Catholics, spread over 226 dioceses. In Germany, however, about 23 million believers are divided into 27 dioceses.

Individual cases

Bassetti's promise will have to be seen as a response to the results of the recent investigation on sexual abuse in the French Roman Catholic Church, even as in the diocese of Munich. The research concluded, among other issues, that clergy ignored cases of abuse in the past. The conclusion was in line with the research results of other countries, such as the Netherlands.

It is unlikely that Italy would be unaffected by the “moral decline of the church”, as pope Benedictus XVI called the abuse by priests. Once in a while, Italian cases of abuse appear in the media. Still, in general, people believe that these are incidental cases.

Righteousness

That abuse remains hidden, could be because of the “influence of the Vatican and the fact that the government and the church hierarchy are intertwined”, Francesco Zanardi, president of Rete Abuso, says to the Italian newspaper Il Fatto Quotidiano. According to Rete Abuso (Network of abuse), which keeps track of the database of cases of abuse, 1000 to 4000 priests have been guilty of paedophilia in the past decades.

From Bassetti's words, it can be concluded that the Italian conference of bishops does not aim to investigate abuse of the past but rather to prevent abuse in the future. “Righteousness should not mean that justice is applied rigidly and drastically”, Bassetti says. “We do not serve anyone by hastily digging up numbers (of abuse cases, ed.) The Italian church has been working on prevention for years (…) We should (…), act strongly to prevent this from happening again.”

*This article was translated by CNE.news and previously published in Dutch daily Reformatorisch Dagblad on February 2th, 2022.*

Back to top button